LibWeb/CSS: Maintain original form of media-feature ranges

Previously, for `foo < 30px` ranges, we'd flip them and store them as
`30px > foo` instead. That worked fine, but means the serialization is
wrong. So instead, keep them in their original form.

I experimented with giving Range two optional sub-structs instead of 4
optional members, thinking it would be smaller - but it's actually
larger, because the two Optional<Comparison>s fit snugly together. So,
the slightly-goofy all-Optionals remains.

This gets us 2 WPT passes that I'm aware of.
This commit is contained in:
Sam Atkins 2025-05-22 12:50:03 +01:00
commit 9fe8445946
Notes: github-actions[bot] 2025-05-23 09:19:11 +00:00
5 changed files with 28 additions and 32 deletions

View file

@ -82,10 +82,14 @@ String MediaFeature::to_string() const
return MUST(String::formatted("max-{}: {}", string_from_media_feature_id(m_id), value().to_string()));
case Type::Range: {
auto& range = this->range();
if (!range.right_comparison.has_value())
return MUST(String::formatted("{} {} {}", range.left_value.to_string(), comparison_string(range.left_comparison), string_from_media_feature_id(m_id)));
StringBuilder builder;
if (range.left_comparison.has_value())
builder.appendff("{} {} ", range.left_value->to_string(), comparison_string(*range.left_comparison));
builder.append(string_from_media_feature_id(m_id));
if (range.right_comparison.has_value())
builder.appendff(" {} {}", comparison_string(*range.right_comparison), range.right_value->to_string());
return MUST(String::formatted("{} {} {} {} {}", range.left_value.to_string(), comparison_string(range.left_comparison), string_from_media_feature_id(m_id), comparison_string(*range.right_comparison), range.right_value->to_string()));
return builder.to_string_without_validation();
}
}
@ -137,12 +141,15 @@ MatchResult MediaFeature::evaluate(HTML::Window const* window) const
case Type::Range: {
auto const& range = this->range();
if (auto const left_result = compare(*window, range.left_value, range.left_comparison, queried_value); left_result != MatchResult::True)
return left_result;
if (range.left_comparison.has_value()) {
if (auto const left_result = compare(*window, *range.left_value, *range.left_comparison, queried_value); left_result != MatchResult::True)
return left_result;
}
if (range.right_comparison.has_value())
if (range.right_comparison.has_value()) {
if (auto const right_result = compare(*window, queried_value, *range.right_comparison, *range.right_value); right_result != MatchResult::True)
return right_result;
}
return MatchResult::True;
}

View file

@ -132,7 +132,6 @@ public:
return adopt_own(*new MediaFeature(Type::MaxValue, id, move(value)));
}
// Corresponds to `<mf-range>` grammar, with a single comparison
static NonnullOwnPtr<MediaFeature> half_range(MediaFeatureValue value, Comparison comparison, MediaFeatureID id)
{
return adopt_own(*new MediaFeature(Type::Range, id,
@ -141,6 +140,14 @@ public:
.left_comparison = comparison,
}));
}
static NonnullOwnPtr<MediaFeature> half_range(MediaFeatureID id, Comparison comparison, MediaFeatureValue value)
{
return adopt_own(*new MediaFeature(Type::Range, id,
Range {
.right_comparison = comparison,
.right_value = move(value),
}));
}
// Corresponds to `<mf-range>` grammar, with two comparisons
static NonnullOwnPtr<MediaFeature> range(MediaFeatureValue left_value, Comparison left_comparison, MediaFeatureID id, Comparison right_comparison, MediaFeatureValue right_value)
@ -168,8 +175,8 @@ private:
};
struct Range {
MediaFeatureValue left_value;
Comparison left_comparison;
Optional<MediaFeatureValue> left_value {};
Optional<Comparison> left_comparison {};
Optional<Comparison> right_comparison {};
Optional<MediaFeatureValue> right_value {};
};

View file

@ -274,22 +274,6 @@ OwnPtr<MediaFeature> Parser::parse_media_feature(TokenStream<ComponentValue>& to
return {};
};
auto flip = [](MediaFeature::Comparison comparison) {
switch (comparison) {
case MediaFeature::Comparison::Equal:
return MediaFeature::Comparison::Equal;
case MediaFeature::Comparison::LessThan:
return MediaFeature::Comparison::GreaterThan;
case MediaFeature::Comparison::LessThanOrEqual:
return MediaFeature::Comparison::GreaterThanOrEqual;
case MediaFeature::Comparison::GreaterThan:
return MediaFeature::Comparison::LessThan;
case MediaFeature::Comparison::GreaterThanOrEqual:
return MediaFeature::Comparison::LessThanOrEqual;
}
VERIFY_NOT_REACHED();
};
auto comparisons_match = [](MediaFeature::Comparison a, MediaFeature::Comparison b) -> bool {
switch (a) {
case MediaFeature::Comparison::Equal:
@ -322,7 +306,7 @@ OwnPtr<MediaFeature> Parser::parse_media_feature(TokenStream<ComponentValue>& to
tokens.discard_whitespace();
if (!tokens.has_next_token() && !maybe_value->is_ident()) {
transaction.commit();
return MediaFeature::half_range(maybe_value.release_value(), flip(maybe_comparison.release_value()), maybe_name->id);
return MediaFeature::half_range(maybe_name->id, maybe_comparison.release_value(), maybe_value.release_value());
}
}
}