diff --git a/Libraries/LibJS/Runtime/Temporal/PlainDateTimePrototype.cpp b/Libraries/LibJS/Runtime/Temporal/PlainDateTimePrototype.cpp
index 7588099574e..ad2337152f0 100644
--- a/Libraries/LibJS/Runtime/Temporal/PlainDateTimePrototype.cpp
+++ b/Libraries/LibJS/Runtime/Temporal/PlainDateTimePrototype.cpp
@@ -289,7 +289,7 @@ JS_DEFINE_NATIVE_FUNCTION(PlainDateTimePrototype::with)
     auto result = TRY(interpret_temporal_date_time_fields(vm, calendar, fields, overflow));
 
     // 17. Return ? CreateTemporalDateTime(result, calendar).
-    return MUST(create_temporal_date_time(vm, result, calendar));
+    return TRY(create_temporal_date_time(vm, result, calendar));
 }
 
 // 5.3.26 Temporal.PlainDateTime.prototype.withPlainTime ( [ plainTimeLike ] ), https://tc39.es/proposal-temporal/#sec-temporal.plaindatetime.prototype.withplaintime
diff --git a/Libraries/LibJS/Tests/builtins/Temporal/PlainDateTime/PlainDateTime.prototype.with.js b/Libraries/LibJS/Tests/builtins/Temporal/PlainDateTime/PlainDateTime.prototype.with.js
index 1b7ed551623..9d808bcbb2e 100644
--- a/Libraries/LibJS/Tests/builtins/Temporal/PlainDateTime/PlainDateTime.prototype.with.js
+++ b/Libraries/LibJS/Tests/builtins/Temporal/PlainDateTime/PlainDateTime.prototype.with.js
@@ -80,4 +80,12 @@ describe("errors", () => {
             new Temporal.PlainDateTime(1970, 1, 1).with({ timeZone: {} });
         }).toThrowWithMessage(TypeError, "Object must be a partial Temporal object");
     });
+
+    test("invalid ISO date range", () => {
+        const plainDateTime = new Temporal.PlainDateTime(-271821, 4, 19, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1);
+
+        expect(() => {
+            plainDateTime.with({ nanosecond: 0 });
+        }).toThrowWithMessage(RangeError, "Invalid plain date time");
+    });
 });